The Haaland Conundrum: As the Goal Spigot Closes, Can Manchester City’s Collective Step Up?
The inevitable has finally happened. After a relentless, record-shattering procession of goals, the tap has been temporarily turned off. Erling Haaland, the Nordic force of nature whose very presence has redefined Manchester City’s attack, has seen a notable scoring streak come to an end. The statistical anomaly has normalized, and for the first time in a while, a match has passed without his name appearing on the scoresheet. In the wake of this quietude, a question that has simmered beneath the surface of City’s success is now being asked with renewed urgency and volume: In the era of Haaland, has this become a team of “Haaland or Bust”?
The evidence for the prosecution is compelling. When the Norwegian cyborg is fit, firing, and converting the chances laid on a platter for him by Kevin De Bruyne, Bernardo Silva, and Phil Foden, City look unstoppable. They are a machine with a perfect, devastatingly efficient end product. The system, honed by Pep Guardiola over years, now has its ultimate focal point—a predator who transforms half-chances into goals and dominant possession into unassailable leads. His goal-scoring runs are not just impressive; they are the engine of victory.
However, his recent quiet period—a relative term, meaning merely a game or two without a goal—has coincided with a slight stutter in the team’s otherwise imperious march. A draw that should have been a win. A performance where 70% possession translated into only a handful of clear-cut chances. Suddenly, the attacking play that once seemed fluid and multi-faceted can appear one-dimensional, funneling towards the number 9. The strategy can devolve into a hopeful search for Haaland’s run, rather than a patient construction of a guaranteed opportunity. This is the inherent risk of housing such a unique talent; the team can subconsciously outsource its goal-scoring responsibility.
This is not a criticism of Haaland, but a scrutiny of the ecosystem around him. The departure of key figures like İlkay Gündoğan, a player who possessed a unique knack for arriving in the box to score crucial, late goals, is felt more acutely in these moments. When Haaland is marked out of a game by two physical centre-backs, or when his supply lines are cut, the question becomes: who else will provide the decisive blow?
The answer, according to pundits, former players, and a growing section of the fanbase, must be a collective one. The burden to “elevate their game” does not fall on one pair of shoulders, but several.
First and foremost is **Phil Foden**. The “Stockport Iniesta” possesses world-class technical ability and a eye for goal that has been evident since his academy days. The call now is for him to transition from a brilliant supporting actor to a leading man who can consistently deliver 15-20 league goals a season from midfield. He has the capacity to grab a game by the scruff of its neck, to take on the shooting responsibility from distance, and to make the runs into the box that complement, rather than just serve, Haaland.
Then there is **Julián Álvarez**. The World Cup winner is a curious case of a world-class striker forced into a supporting role. His natural instinct is to score, and he has shown he can do so when given the chance. In a system without a traditional number nine, Álvarez would be a prolific forward. His challenge is to find a way to consistently impact the scoreboard from a slightly deeper, more creative position, becoming a genuine second goal threat that prevents opponents from focusing solely on Haaland.
The returning **Kevin De Bruyne** also holds a key. While his primary function is creation, his own threat from outside the box is a devastating weapon. Defenders who drop off to cover Haaland’s runs create space for De Bruyne to unleash his thunderous shot. A more selfish De Bruyne in certain situations could be a necessary evil, adding another layer of unpredictability to City’s attack.
This is the delicate balancing act Pep Guardiola must now master. His philosophy has always been about the collective, about a system that is greater than the sum of its parts. The incorporation of Haaland was the ultimate test of this philosophy—could a system built on interchanging parts and fluid possession integrate a fixed, terminal point? The answer, for the most part, has been a resounding yes.
But the next evolution, as one streak ends and the grind of a long season intensifies, is to ensure the system does not atrophy around its star. Guardiola’s task is to re-calibrate, to drill into his squad that while they have the best striker in the world, they cannot become dependent on him. The “step up” required is a mental one as much as a technical one. It is about the winger taking on the defender instead of looking for the cross, the midfielder driving into the box with conviction, and the entire team rediscovering the shared goal-scoring responsibility that defined their pre-Haaland era.
The end of a scoring streak is not a crisis for Manchester City. It is a natural occurrence in the ebb and flow of a football season. But it serves as a vital stress test, a revealing glimpse into the team’s tactical and psychological constitution. Is this a “Haaland or Bust” operation? The coming weeks will provide the answer. If players like Foden, Álvarez, and others can consistently elevate their game and share the goal-scoring burden, City will have proven their greatness is systemic, not just singular. If not, they risk becoming a team that is brilliant, but also, at times, predictably reliant on one extraordinary man.
Leave a Reply